Law

OAB Sets Rules for Settlements With Legal AI Companies, Saying the Tools Cannot Replace Lawyers

· 6 min read · Law

OAB Sets Rules for Settlements With Legal AI Companies, Saying the Tools Cannot Replace Lawyers

The Federal Council of the Brazilian Bar Association (OAB) has set the terms under which it will sign conduct adjustment agreements, known as TACs, with companies that develop, offer or sell AI tools for legal work, the OAB said on November 20. Resolution 16/2026, published in the OAB’s electronic gazette, aims to protect lawyers’ professional prerogatives and stop technology from being used to improperly replace the work of attorneys. “Artificial intelligence can and should help modernise the legal profession, but it cannot replace the work of lawyers,” said OAB national president Beto Simonetti.

Under the rule, the Federal Council’s board can decide case by case whether to negotiate an agreement to prevent, halt or correct practices that conflict with the Statute of the Legal Profession. Negotiating does not rule out lawsuits or out-of-court measures, including urgent ones. The guidelines include preserving activities reserved to lawyers, human supervision of automated features, protection of professional secrecy and personal data, and transparency in how legal services are offered. The resolution also targets improper capture of clients, the commercialisation of the profession and advertising that leads the public to believe an AI system can stand in for a lawyer.

What it means in practice

OAB Sets Rules for Settlements With Legal AI Companies, Saying the Tools Cannot Replace Lawyers — contextual photo

For legal-tech firms, the resolution creates a route to settle with the OAB instead of facing court, but on the bar’s terms. Any agreement must set obligations, deadlines and follow-up mechanisms, and may include inspections, audits and correction of irregular practices. The OAB stressed that signing a TAC does not amount to approval, certification or endorsement of any company, platform or product. The text follows a decision by the OAB’s full council on August 17, adopted by acclamation, authorising legal action against companies that violate professional prerogatives when selling AI solutions. Simonetti said the aim is to make technology respect prerogatives, legal certainty and the rights of citizens who need legal help, without giving up the benefits of innovation.

The framework arrives after a run of disputes in court: a federal judge denied OAB-SP’s bid to halt Enter’s legal AI but ordered records kept, and the Rio bar asked to join the São Paulo lawsuit. What to watch is which companies seek a TAC first, whether the Enter case ends in one, and where the OAB draws the line between tools that assist lawyers and services offered directly to the public.

← Back to AI4Brazil